Thursday, December 13, 2007

The Politics of Music

On Monday, December 10th, the New York Philharmonic announced that it will be traveling to North Korea to perform a concert there on February 26th. The concert, which will come at the end of the orchestra's China tour, will include pieces by Gershwin, Dvorak and both the US and North Korean national anthem.

What has startled me most about this recent announcement is the negative reaction it has received from some. For example, I heard Terry Teachout interviewed on CNN just before the announcement was official and he berated the orchestra for crossing boundaries of political hostilities. If the United States has diplomatic sanctions on North Korea, he argued, why should we freely offer them our musical pleasures?

This point of view seems to me to show an egregious misunderstanding of music's role in history as a political equalizer. Perhaps I'm under the influence of The Rest is Noise, but even during the totalitarian reigns of Hitler and Stalin when music was at its most highly politicized, music served as a no man's land where many composers were able to communicate with the outside through their universal language. Even some Jewish musicians were spared by Hitler because their musicality raised them above their ethnicity. Can't that same universality help us today, even if classical music isn't the soul of our culture as it perhaps used to be? I guess I should be heartened that an orchestra's touring schedule still has the power to elicit passionate responses from politicians, journalists and music fans alike.

Monday, December 10, 2007

Edith Piaf: The Voice of France


Biopics are no new thing in film. 2007 saw its fair share: Jane Austen, Beatrix Potter and Truman Capote have all had screen time recently. Musicians Ray Charles and Johnny Cash also received attention in recent years. But not one biography of an artist has gripped me like La Vie en Rose, the summer release based on the life of legendary French singer Edith Piaf which I saw for the first time the other night.

Aside from the tragic life that made for fast-paced and wrenching storytelling, Piaf's original music fantastically illustrates the atmosphere of France before and after World War II. Her gutteral tone--almost speaking on pitch-- is so closely associated with French folk singing that I, not having heard any particular Edith Piaf recordings before this movie, instinctively understood the cultural setting of the movie.

Also remarkable about this film is the performance of Marion Cotillard, who plays Edith Piaf. It's hard to believe Cotillard is the beautiful young woman who co-stars with Russell Crowe in A Good Year. And it's hard to believe that the same actress plays Piaf through all her adult years; she changes so dramatically in her appearance and demeanor as her character grows older and more sickly.

I have already searched iTunes for Piaf's best-loved songs. Her voice, while not always beautiful, spoke the language of a whole people.

Friday, November 30, 2007

Review: Browns in Blue (The 5 Browns)


I've followed the five Brown siblings for several years now for two reasons: 1) because they are Mormon and attend the same church I went to as a child, across from Juilliard where they study, and I'm always in favor of prominent Mormon musicians; and 2) because they are clearly trying to make classical music "accessible" to people of our generation and I admire their efforts. I've enjoyed this latest album Browns in Blue mostly because each of the selections has a classically beautiful melody, many of which will be recognizable even to those who don't follow piano repertoire (except for the arrangement on the Vaughn Williams hymn "If You Could Hie to Kolob" which will mostly likely only be recognized by LDS people). The siblings are clearly targeting a younger listener who needs a little glamor and schmaltz to go with an all-acoustic recording, and I for one enjoy their glitzy poses and hang-loose personalities.

I have two complaints, however. In all the marketing and comfortable programming, I feel that the individual artistic temperaments have been sacrificed. Presumably each of these siblings has a distinct style or taste that varies (however insignificantly) from the others'. But you'd never know it as one carefully executed piece by one sibling moves right along to another carefully executed piece by another. I'd like a little more blood and guts left on the floor of the recording studio-- I'd like to be able to tell when Greg is playing or when it's Deondra-- but perhaps the ensemble work that's brought them fame has also diminished their individually passionate voices.

The Chopin Nocture (Op 48 No 1) played by Greg seemed to me to have the most soul and drive of any of the pieces on the recording. A rather adventurous video of his "Superstar Etude" suggests that there's something more under his surface, which, for me, is reassuring.

Secondly, I come away from the 5 Browns' recordings feeling that the potential of five pianos being played at once has barely been scratched. What a thunderously rich, orchestral noise five pianos can make together! And yet the arrangements in which all five of them are playing suggest to my ear that each of the siblings is perhaps playing a single line, or a simplified part, rather than a fully developed polyphony. I compare their arrangements to those Leif Ove Andsnes emplyed at his Risor festival when he gathered 10 of the greatest pianists in the world and had them play everything from Bach to a Jamaican Rumba.

All in all, I am thrilled for the 5 Browns and would reach for their latest if I were to recommend an introductory piano recording to a friend. It's happy, untortured stuff and for that I am grateful.

Wednesday, November 28, 2007

A Palette Cleanser After Too Much Turkey...

The Friday after Thanksgiving, my dad and I went to a matinee at Symphony Hall to hear the BSO perform Smetana's Overture to The Bartered Bride and Ma Vlast, his symphonic work of six tone poems. As a patriotic composer, Smetana is often overshadowed by his Czech countryman Dvorak who also made ample use of native folk tunes. James Levine is a "complete, unabashed Smetana nut," according to his program notes, and since I've never actually heard Ma Vlast performed, I was anxious to hear his usual unbridled enthusiasm in full force.

Perhaps it was all the 20th Century stuff I've been listening to in conjunction with reading The Rest is Noise, but Smetana's overwrought string work and alternating dominant/tonics sounded more like movie music to me rather than the "masterpiece" Levine claims it is. Not that that is a bad thing: after too much Stravinsky and Mahler, some good ole symphonic storytelling was an effective palette cleanser! I left the concert feeling ready to dive head first back into the Russian and German totalitarianism of the 1940s.

Wednesday, November 21, 2007

Alex Ross Live


On Monday night, I left the kids with E and ventured into Harvard Square to hear Alex Ross, the author of The Rest is Noise, speak at the Harvard Book Store. I felt very cool indeed as I took my place among the graduate students and professorial types; kind of an out of body experience actually as I haven't been one of the academic crowd for so very long.

Ross spoke initially about himself and how he came to write such a book: as an undergraduate at Harvard he had been involved with the campus radio station and discovered many forgotten LPs among the station's library that introduced him to 20th sounds, both classical and popular. His stated mission is to make clear the connections between classical music and the rest of the 20th century, both politically and musically, but intertwining music with stories of governments, wars and personal histories. He clearly has a thorough analytical understanding of how music came to be the way it is today, and in what way each genre owes its dept to traditional Eurocentric music of the past.

As a speaker, Ross is remarkably eloquent. His book is written in a comfortable yet nourishing style, and his speech is the same. He stated that his book hosts three different conversations: the first is a discussion of the "explosion of style" that defined 20th century music; the second is the discussion of how "politics and music intermingle" with the composers "becoming soldiers"; and third, a discussion of the "lonely, outlying figures" like Sibelius who didn't define new styles or revolutionize sound and therefore are often overlooked in histories of the period.

The only thing that disappointed me was that he was not nearly as witty as I had hoped he'd be. This was important to me not because I was in the mood for jokes, but because I've felt through his writing that he's been able to lighten the atmosphere surrounding classical music and I was hoping his personality would convey an equal lightheartedness about his subject. I feel strongly that classical music could use some advocates who don't take things quite so seriously, who are able to convey the joy and all-consuming nature of music study without bogging it down in the ladder-climbing and self-satisfaction of the academic elite. Ross' writings have done the entire industry a huge service in this regard, but I still feel that academics, journalists and business people within the field of classical music could make further strides in readjusting the industry's perceived uber-seriousness.

Perhaps I'm looking for a public figure who, through sheer force of personality, could lift the industry out of its "obscure pandemonium" (as Alex Ross says) up to a place of mainstream recognition. With Pavarotti's death so recently behind us, his image comes to mind. Is there an academic or a business leader who could have a similar effect, making not only "Nessun Dorma" widely recognized but the whole language of classical music?

Thursday, November 15, 2007

Mahler's the Name of the Day -- Again

So today, after Levine and Walter, I listened to Simon Rattle's version of the Mahler 9, which he just performed with the Berlin Philharmonic in New York as part of Carnegie Hall's 17-day Berlin in Lights festival. Reading the New York Times' ArtsBeat blog about the festival, it makes me think that there is a non-condescending way to do thematic programming after all. All of New York --from Chinatown to St. John the Divine -- have been introduced to the sounds and talents of Berlin over the past week. The musical energy in the city this week has had a little help from Gustavo Dudamel and the Simon Bolivar Youth Orchestra who, according to YouTube footage, have a hard time putting on airs.

Wednesday, November 14, 2007

In Praise of The New Phil

I'd already been playing the piano for a year by the time I was my daughter's age. I've resisted the ambitious mother's inevitable capitulation to the siren call of Suzuki, but that doesn't mean I haven't taken her to her fair share of "children's concerts". After four years of them, I've started to dread even the very term. There's been very little that's child-friendly about most of the ones we've attended: they're still in large, intimidating concert halls where the kids are preferred, if not expected, to be quiet and take what's good for them. But last Saturday, the little one and I ventured out to the Newton Cultural Center where we sat on the floor in a converted gym and listened to the New Philharmonia Orchestra play to fifty toddlers and their parents.

The last movement of Dvorak's 6th symphony was first on the program. Little E was sitting on my lap, and at the first crashing chords she looked up at me and said, "Wow!" Wow, it was loud! Wow it was cool to be sitting so close. Wow it was cool to be able to say wow and not have other (better) parents look at my kid and go "Shh." After that, there was a very coherent explanation by a first violinist of the term "ostinatto" and a selection from Holst in which the kids sang along with the ostinatto. Finally, a series of variations on Yankee Doodle showing off each instrument in the orchestra and with the vocal talents of a local 3rd grade. Little E was in awe.

The afternoon finished with an "instrument petting zoo" -- E tried a pint sized cello, violin, trumpet, horn, trombone, and snare drum. ("And triangle!" she reminded her dad.) Fabulous.